No model, dataset, or result has been selected. The first deliverable is a fair comparison, not a dashboard.
The Cost of Being Wrong
A working investigation into a question worth keeping open.
Open QuestionHow should a decision system represent uncertainty when the cost of one kind of mistake is much larger than another?
Question
UNN-002 / starting point
How should a decision system represent uncertainty when the cost of one kind of mistake is much larger than another?
Source
What is inherited
The starting observation is practical: two decisions can have the same probability and radically different consequences if one mistake is harder to reverse.
This is a problem framing, not a claim that a single risk formula can represent a person’s life.
Interpretation
What we are doing with it
Decision support may need to show the shape of an error, not only its likelihood: who absorbs it, how quickly it arrives, and whether a safer next step preserves options.
Hypothesis
A claim we can try to weaken
A system that makes asymmetric downside visible may help people choose more reversible next moves without pretending uncertainty can be removed.
Experiment
What would count as a fair test
Create a small set of paired scenarios with equal probabilities but different reversibility and human cost.
Compare a probability-only summary with a context-rich summary, then inspect where human judgments change and why.
The experiment has not been run. No performance claim is implied.
Counterexample
The useful objection
- Making downside more vivid can create fear rather than clarity. A risk-aware system may become over-cautious precisely when a bold move is needed.
Findings
Evidence status
NOT YET TESTED
- This investigation is planned. There are no findings to report.
Open Questions
What remains open
- Can reversibility be described without flattening lived context into a score?
- Which parts of an error should belong to the system, and which belong to the person deciding?
- What would count as a useful disagreement between a model and a human?
Loose pages from the workbench
Lab notes
Atmosphere, not evidence.
Visual plates from the SisiTheFox room



